Dice la canción

Bloody revolutions de Crass

album

Best before 1984

14 de diciembre de 2011

Significado de Bloody revolutions

collapse icon

La canción "Bloody Revolutions" interpretada por Crass y contenida en el álbum Best Before 1984, pertenece a un género musical punk/anarcho-punk. Publicada originalmente en 1980, esta pista se destaca por su tono provocativo y crítico hacia la violencia revolucionaria.

Las letras de esta canción cuestionan el concepto de revolución basada en la violencia como medio para lograr un cambio político. Se plantea la interrogante sobre si aquellos que promueven la revolución estarían dispuestos a llevar a cabo actos violentos y derramar sangre en nombre de sus ideales. Se resalta que la libertad no tiene valor si el precio es la violencia, en contraposición con el deseo del cantante de alcanzar una anarquía pacífica.

El mensaje subyacente apunta a criticar la idea de imponer restricciones y nuevos regímenes a aquellos que se oponen a las convicciones del movimiento revolucionario. Se señala que, en caso de discrepancia, se recurre a eliminar físicamente a quienes no estén de acuerdo con las ideas predominantes. La canción plantea un dilema ético al cuestionar si la violencia revolucionaria conduce realmente a una mayor libertad y justicia social.

Se hace referencia al uso histórico del gas Zyklon B durante el Holocausto nazi para ilustrar cómo la implementación violenta de ideas extremas puede conducir a atrocidades inimaginables. Asimismo, se critica la creencia simplista de que una revolución resolverá todos los problemas sociales sin tener en cuenta las consecuencias trágicas y humanas detrás de los actos violentos impulsados por ideologías extremistas.

La canción invita a reflexionar sobre las implicaciones reales y los dilemas morales ligados a las luchas ideológicas extremas. Cuestiona el romanticismo asociado con líderes revolucionarios pasados como Marx o Mao al señalar que sus ideas originales ahora pueden traducirse en formas opresivas de gobierno.

A través de sus letras desafiantes, "Bloody Revolutions" busca desmitificar las falacias detrás del poder político tanto en el espectro derechista como izquierdista, argumentando que debajo de diferentes etiquetas políticas, persiste una estructura autoritaria común que prioriza el control sobre la verdadera libertad individual.

En resumen, Crass plantea una advertencia contra caer en trampas ideológicas extremistas que justifiquen medidas violentas en nombre del progreso social y político. La canción reitera que buscar cambios significativos requiere evitar idealizaciones simplistas y reconocer los peligros inherentes al uso indiscriminado de la fuerza como instrumento político.

Interpretación del significado de la letra realizada con IA.

You talk about your revolution, well, that's fine
but what are you going to be doing come the time?
are you going to be the big man with the tommy-gun?
will you talk of freedom when the blood begins to run?
well, freedom has no value if violence is the price
don't want your revolution, i want anarchy and peace
You talk of overthrowing power with violence as your tool
you speak of liberation and when the people rule
well ain't it people rule right now, what difference would there be?
just another set of bigots with their rifle-sights on me
But what about those people who don't want your new restrictions?
those that disagree with you and have their own convictions?
you say they've got it wrong because they don't agree with you
so when the revolution comes you'll have to run them through
you say that revolution will bring freedom for us all
well freedom just ain't freedom when your back's against the wall
You talk of overthrowing power with violence as your tool
you speak of liberation and when the people rule
well ain't it people rule right now, what difference would there be?
just another set of bigots with their rifle-sights on me
Will you indoctrinate the masses to serve your new regime?
and simply do away with those whose views are too extreme?
transportation details could be left to british rail
where zyklon b succeeded, north sea gas will fail
it's just the same old story of man destroying man
we've got to look for other answers to the problems of this land
You talk of overthrowing power with violence as your tool
you speak of liberation and when the people rule
well ain't it people rule right now, what difference would there be?
just another set of bigots with their rifle-sights on me
Vive la revolution, people of the world unite
stand up men of courage, it's your job to fight
It all seems very easy, this revolution game
but when you start to really play things won't be quite the same
your intellectual theories on how it's going to be
don't seem to take into account the true reality
cos the truth of what you're saying, as you sit there sipping beer
is pain and death and suffering, but of course you wouldn't care
You're far too much of a man for that, if mao did it so can you
what's the freedom of us all against the suffering of the few?
that's the kind of self-deception that killed ten million jews
just the same false logic that all power-mongers use
so don't think you can fool me with your political tricks
political right, political left, you can keep your politics
government is government and all government is force
left or right, right or left, it takes the same old course
oppression and restriction, regulation, rule and law
the seizure of that power is all your revolution's for
you romanticise your heroes, quote from marx and mao
well their ideas of freedom are just oppression now
Nothing changed for all the death, that their ideas created
it's just the same fascistic games, but the rules aren't clearly stated
nothing's really different cos all government's the same
they can call it freedom, but slavery is the game
Nothing changed for all the death, that their ideas created
it's just the same fascistic games, but the rules aren't clearly stated
nothing's really different cos all government's the same
they can call it freedom, but slavery is the game
there's nothing that you offer but a dream of last years hero
the truth of revolution, year zero.

Letra traducida a Español

Traducción de la letra realizada con IA.

0

0